Order Delivery or Carry-Out with Old Town Pizza

Stay safe and support your favorite local Italian eatery by ordering your next family meal from Old Town Pizzeria. To us, our customers are our family, even if they are unable to dine in with us at this time. We know you have a lot on your plate these days, so take a break and let us cook up your next lunch or dinner, conveniently available for delivery or carry-out.

port jefferson best pizza near me

Who doesn’t love pizza? And here at Old Town Pizzeria, we certainly know a good pie. We offer a variety of crusts — from our classic hand tossed, pan cooked, and ultra thin, as well as cauliflower and gluten-free options, we have a crust to suit everyone’s tastebuds. Build your own pizza with our wide selection of meats and veggies, or choose from one of our favorite creations, like the Crispino Pizza — a thin pan-cooked pie with fresh mozzarella, tomato slices, roasted red peppers, and accented with a balsamic glaze and basil pesto — truly divine!

For meat lovers, we have numerous chicken and veal options, or try one of our heros piled high with sausage and meatballs on our melt-in-your-mouth garlic bread. If seafood is more your thing, we recommend the Zuppa di Pesce — calamari, clams, mussels, scallops, and shrimp in a plum tomato or garlic white wine sauce and your choice of pasta.

And to our vegetarian friends, we got you covered, too. Our eggplant is expertly prepared and served in every way you could imagine, or opt for an order of our crowd-pleasing Crispy Artichoke or Zucchini Sticks.

Complement your meal with one of our flavorful fresh salads, which can also be served chopped! Add a pint or quart of one of our hearty soups and an order of our garlic or buffalo knots, and you have a complete meal that will make everyone in the family happy.

Old Town Pizzeria is located at 691 Old Town Rd in Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776. We are open Monday-Saturday 10am-10pm with Carry-Out and Delivery available.

For your convenience, you can place an order online through chownow.com here. If you have any questions, please give us a call at 631-473-3712. We look forward to serving you!

Contact Us


old town pizzeria italian restaurant near me
Website design by Digisphere Marketing